In Part 2 of our exploration of how professional independent trustees should go about setting a trust’s overall investment strategy, we looked at the process of defining success, drafting an investment success statement, and translating that statement into investment goals such as current income and growth over time. If you haven’t read it, or don’t remember it, take a moment to read it now before proceeding; the concept of risk is inextricably linked to the definition of success and the investment objectives you quantified, and as a trustee, you cannot draft an investment strategy that adequately identifies and mitigates investment risk until you have a clear definition of success and investment objectives.
Why? Because genuine risk is not stock market volatility, the potential for loss, or any other investment-specific risk you can think of. Genuine risk is the possibility of failure; the possibility that the trust fails to succeed, as you’ve defined it. Yes, investment-specific risks play a role in how you draft the overall investment strategy. But investment-related risks are a subsidiary layer that vary depending on what failure looks like at the trust level, and what investment failure looks like.
To help frame the connection between success and failure, the investment strategy and investment objectives and investment risks, think of success and failure as the primary considerations opposite each other, investment success and failure as elements that help determine trust success or failure, and investment-specific objectives and investment-specific risks as the specific factors that determine investment success or failure. The schematic looks like this:
So how do you identify and address trust risk, investment failure, and subsequently investment-specific risk?
Start by defining failure. Not investment failure. Trust failure. Ask yourself, “What outcomes would constitute failure?” Your answers will be direct, inverse statements of your definition of success. “Inability to support a current or future beneficiary’s education desires.” “Inability to facilitate a current or future beneficiary’s effort to purchase a home or start a business.” “Inability to support a current or future beneficiary in a way that allows them to pursue a career focused primarily on their passion to serve others regardless of the salary it provides.” “Failure to perpetuate the principal values cherished by the grantors.” “Failure to maintain family harmony and connectedness”.
Each of these failure statements highlights potential risk to the extent each statement may materialize. Some of these failure statements are inherently investment-centric, some of them are not. But trust failures may arise from seemingly unrelated investment failures. For example, “Failure to maintain family harmony and connectedness” may result from an unnecessarily aggressive investment strategy that prioritizes certain family members with a high emotional risk tolerance over family members with a low emotional risk tolerance. In such a situation, the trust’s failure to maintain family harmony and cohesiveness is due to an investment failure, an investment strategy that failed to properly balance the emotional risk tolerances of all beneficiaries.
So, just as you drafted a written statement of success that succinctly synthesizes and priorities it all, define failure and draft a written failure statement that succinctly synthesizes and prioritizes the various aspects you considered in drafting it. Then draft an investment failure statement that corresponds to your trust-level failure statement. It will likely touch on similar elements that your investment success statement touches on.
Once both of those are in place, you’re ready to identify, evaluate, prioritize, and where possible, mitigate the investment-specific risks that are essential elements in a trust’s overall investment strategy. You’re asking, “What are the key investment-specific risks that could produce an investment failure?” Because investment-related risk comes in many forms, and to better understand how the trust and investment failure statements you drafted correspond to investment-specific risks, let’s consider a few specific examples.
Let’s look first at investment-specific risks that could impair a trust’s ability to meet its income generation objectives. Generating current and future income is a function of a) the value of trust assets, b) the nature of trust assets and their income-generating potential (privately held businesses, real estate, mineral rights etc.), c) current yields offered by other potential assets, and d) the desired amount and timing of income you identified as necessary when you drafted the trust’s investment objectives. You should incorporate these characteristics when identifying and evaluating income-specific investment risks, which include:
- Inflation risk – the requirement that income generation must grow over time to maintain a beneficiary’s purchasing power and quality of life. Income-producing assets may contain inflation-adjustment mechanisms, but many do not; the income they generate remains flat over time, making each successive dollar of income earned less valuable.
- Credit risk – the risk that an income-paying asset fails to continually pay income as scheduled or fails to return all capital upon maturity. Higher income-producing assets tend to have higher credit risk.
- Interest rate risk – the risk that as market-based interest rates rise, the price of the income-producing assets in the trust fall, pulling the overall value of the trust down.
- Re-investment risk – the risk that when income-generating assets mature or are redeemed, the income produced by the replacement asset is lower than the income previously generated by the maturing asset. Higher income-producing assets tend to have higher reinvestment risk.
- Premium Amortization Risk – the risk that as an income producing asset draws closer to maturity, any price premium above its eventual maturity value erodes, pulling down the overall value of the trust. This risk is particularly acute with many municipal bonds, which, though attractive due to their preferential tax treatment, pay unusually high coupon payments, and because of that, will often be priced at significant premiums to par that erode over time. We’ll explore this particular issue in Part 4 because it comes into play when a trust has multiple generations or multiple classes of beneficiaries.
- Illiquidity Risk – the risk that the trust is unable to sell or liquidate an asset in order to meet distribution requirements. This is particularly relevant today for a number of alternative asset classes, a topic we’ll explore in more detail in a future segment of this series.
For principal beneficiaries, some of these same risks apply, including inflation risk, credit risk, interest rate risk, premium amortization risk and illiquidity risk because they intrinsically include the risk of loss of principal. But principal beneficiaries also face additional investment-specific risks, including:
- Economic risk – the risk that the domestic or global economy enters a recession or fails to grow sufficiently fast.
- Market risk – commonly referred to as market volatility, the risk that the asset class declines in value. What most trustees and amateur investors think of when they think of risk.
- Sector risk – the risk that a specific sector, which may be an economic sector like information technology or health care, or investment sector like cryptocurrency, high yield bonds or venture capital, declines in value.
- Asset-specific risk – the risk that an individual asset declines in value, often due to poor execution by those managing the asset, as in the case of a privately held business.
- Regulatory, Legal, and/or Political Risk – the risk that regulatory policies, laws or lawsuits, as in the case of intellectual property, or political agendas create a decline in value.
It’s important to note that for principal beneficiaries, a temporary decline in value is only a risk if a) it coincides with the timing of principal distributions (withdrawing assets while values are depressed leaves the trust with fewer assets to capitalize on the ensuing rebound) or b) the temporary decline occurs repeatedly or is unusually large, often owing to imprudent or negligent management, and results in a lower long-term growth rate over time.
Which highlights another important point; the real risk for beneficiaries isn’t actually market volatility or a temporary decline in value per se. The real risk is that market volatility or another investment-specific risk factor materially impairs a trust’s capacity to achieve a long-term rate of return sufficient to facilitate future principal distributions.
For this reason, when drafting the investment strategy, and specifically the investment objectives and risks, you should establish and quantify goals for current income and a long-term growth rate, which can be absolute, as in the case of a long-term growth rate “equal to or better than 8% on average annually”, or relative, as in the case of a long-term growth rate “equal to inflation plus 4%”, as an example.
When you quantify both the income and growth goals, you will have two corresponding investment risks; the risk that the trust fails to generate a certain amount of income and the risk that the trust fails to produce your established long-term required rate of return. These are the two risks you should focus on most, with the understanding that every other investment-specific risk will either increase or decrease one or both of these two risks.
We should also note, investment-specific risks will vary in terms of probability, consequence, and your ability to mitigate or control for them. Some may have a low probability but a catastrophic consequence that you can’t adequately control or mitigate, while others may have a relatively high probability, a moderate consequence, but can be appropriately controlled or mitigated. Therefore, we suggest that as you identify risks, consider using a ratings scale across all three axes (probability, consequence, controllability / mitigation) so you can quickly identify which risks are most pertinent and deserve the most focus, and which risks are less pertinent and deserve less focus.
You will find that some risks are correlated, in that they will rise and fall together, as in the case of inflation risk and interest rate risk, which tend to be correlated; as inflation expectations rise, interest rates tend to rise. On the other hand, many risks are oppositional; you can reduce reinvestment risk by owning income producing assets with long maturities, but doing so potentially elevates credit risk, inflation risk, interest rate risk and premium amortization risk.
Finally, if nothing else, remember this axiom: Investment risk and return are always two sides of the same coin. You cannot have any potential return without some potential risk, and you cannot have higher potential investment returns without higher potential investment risk. Your obligation as trustee is to identify and assess the investment returns (income and growth broadly speaking) that best support the trust’s success, the investment-specific risks that most threaten the trust’s success, and then develop an investment strategy that balances it all. Like most tasks you perform as trustee, this is 75% art, 25% science.
Speaking of art, in Part 4, we’ll explore the art of balancing the interests and desires of various, sometimes competing, beneficiary classes.
If you liked this piece and want to continue to receive them, please follow Third Day Capital Management on LinkedIn. And of course, if you have any specific questions, feel free to reach out to us directly. We prefer personal conversations, but email or LinkedIn messages work just fine.


