Previously, we began a multi-part exploration of your role as an independent trustee in establishing the overall investment strategy for your trusts. We looked at your non-delegable obligation to set the trust’s “North Star” and we promised to explore the specific trust and beneficiary circumstances you should consider when setting the trust’s overall investment strategy. As promised, we will look at those factors in this Part 2.
But asking “What factors should I consider when setting the investment strategy?”, while sensible, is the wrong question to approach the process with. Focusing on which factors to consider unintentionally narrows your attention to the inputs at the risk of losing sight of your desired outcome for the trust. So we’re going to approach this process from a different perspective.
Because setting the investment strategy is more nuanced than simply considering a few factors and making a decision. Your role as trustee requires you to synthesize disparate pieces of information, resolve the tensions between them, make value judgements, prioritize and deprioritize various factors, and to translate it all into a cohesive strategic plan of action. It’s not a simple process; when setting the investment strategy, you are essentially writing an entire symphony.
So, Mozart, how do you begin?
Begin with the end. Ask yourself, “What does success look like?” Not investment success. Success. How does/would the grantor define success? How do the beneficiaries define success? How do you define success as the trustee? What values are reflected in the trust? How should your definition of success reinforce them? When those values inevitably conflict, how should they be resolved in light of how you define success?
Notice the change in perspective? We’re not asking an input-centric question that triggers a fact-finding mission. We’re asking a strategic outcome-based question oriented towards a vision of success, which then points toward those factors we should consider and how to prioritize them when they conflict. So, how do we go about defining success?
We can start with the purpose of the trust, the grantor(s) intentions, desires, and values, each of which are likely to be multi-faceted. If you have access to the grantor(s), discuss success with them. If not, you’ll have to resort to the trust documents for context.
Most trust documents will include a purpose statement, but they are often intentionally vague, especially if the grantor wanted to provide a high degree of flexibility and discretion for the trustee. So, as you review the trust documents, you’ll likely need to read between the lines, drawing conclusions and making inferences from the various trust provisions themselves.
Some trust provisions will speak more directly to your definition of success. Specifically, you’ll want to note how many beneficiaries have rights under the trust, how they are prioritized, and whether they span multiple generations. You’ll also want to focus on the distribution provisions, noting whether distributions are optional or mandatory, whether distributions can be both income and principal, and the standards, if any, to make those distributions. Sometimes grantors will explicitly identify circumstances in which they want distributions to be made. When you feel you have enough clarity to do so, draft a success statement from the perspective of the grantor(s). Remember, this is not an investment-focused success statement. This is a general success statement as you believe the grantor(s) would define it.
You can then assess how the beneficiaries define success. For this step, it’s best to keep things simple. Ask them about their goals in life and the timing of those goals. Again, these are not financial goals specifically, they are life goals that have financial considerations which the trust can help them meet. You are asking them, “How can the trust best support you as you strive to meet your goals in life?”
In our experience, most everyone can provide a list of goals because most people have a vision for their lives and a general idea of what “success” looks like. Keep in mind however, their definition of success may conflict with how the grantor(s) define success and/or with how other beneficiaries define success.
This is where values come into play – the values espoused in the trust will shape to a large degree how your beneficiaries’ definitions of success are translated into the trust’s definition of success. Some beneficiary goals (like education or career support) likely coincide with the values expressed in the trust, and they should, accordingly, be part of the trust’s definition of success. Other goals, like extravagant travel or a luxurious lifestyle may not fit with the trust’s expressed values, and therefore, should be excluded in the final definition of success. Ultimately, it’s your responsibility to determine which and to what extent your beneficiary definitions of success are included in your definition of success for the trust.
Which leads us to the final and complete definition of success; yours. With an idea of how both the grantor(s) and beneficiaries define success, you can now draft the trust’s overall success statement. How do you, as the trustee, define success? This will be the definition of success for the trust. It should be an “and” statement that synthesizes the grantor’s definition of success and the beneficiaries’ definition of success. It will almost certainly incorporate the term “facilitate”, followed by various non-financial outcomes for your beneficiaries. It may explicitly incorporate the transmission of or support for the key values you identified during the process. As a side note, your definition of success can also be used as a litmus test for determining whether or how certain distributions should be made.
Once you have defined success at the trust level, setting the investment strategy becomes a matter of answering similar questions; what does investment success look like, in light of the trust’s overall definition of success? What values should the investment strategy reflect and reinforce? When those values inevitably conflict, how should I resolve those conflicts in light of how I’ve defined investment success? You are defining what success looks like for the trust in its entirety, and then defining what success looks like as it relates to the investment strategy, so that the investment strategy’s success is aligned with and supports the trust’s definition of success.
Once investment success is defined, you can establish investment goals and quantify them. What does the trust need to accomplish financially in order to succeed? What amount of current income does the trust need to generate? What growth rate does the trust need to achieve over time? How tax efficient does the trust need to be, based on how the trust and its distributions are taxed? You are asking, “What are the trust’s financial goals and what constitutes success in achieving them?” This is where your job gets complicated.
You are essentially stepping into the role of a financial planner; the trust’s success depends in large part upon its financial success, which is directly correlated to the unique circumstances and financial goals of your beneficiaries; a group who most likely exhibit varying degrees of financial sophistication, knowledge and resources and often comprise multiple generations, some of which may not actually exist yet. To make matters worse, your living beneficiaries may not have a solid handle on their own financial situation, so they may not be able to quantify how or to what extent the trust can support them because they simply don’t know.
If you find yourself in this situation, you may need to work with them and their existing financial advisor to quantify some of their goals or help them hire a financial advisor that will help them quantify their goals. The trust’s investment goals rely on your beneficiaries’ financial goals, and without clarity from your beneficiaries, you don’t have enough information to draft financial goals for the trust, and therefore, can’t draft the overall investment strategy for the trust. Whether your beneficiaries can’t quantify their goals, or are reluctant to share them with you, this roadblock doesn’t nullify your obligation to establish the trust’s overall investment strategy, so requiring your beneficiaries to quantify their goals may be a decision you have to make in order to establish investment goals and set the overall investment strategy. If for some reason you are unable to determine their goals, note your efforts to do so in your records, and do your best to set investment goals that align with your definition of investment success.
There are so many nuances to this process that to attempt to cover them all would be futile. But frameworks can serve as important guides when grappling with idiosyncrasies. In practice, investing the time required to complete these thought exercises at the outset ultimately make setting the investment strategy much more efficient and effective:
- Define success at the trust level based on the grantor(s) and beneficiaries’ definitions of success. Draft a trust-level success statement.
- Define investment success as it relates to the trust’s success. Draft an investment success statement.
- Establish investment goals that a) support the trust’s investment success and b) dovetail with your beneficiaries’ own goals. Investment goals should quantify, at the very minimum, current income goals and growth goals over time for the trust. The importance of these two metrics will become clear when we cover asset allocation.
One final observation; defining success for the trust is more art than science. You must make inferences, set priorities, tease out values that are often alluded to but not explicitly identified, and balance conflicting interests and rights in a professional and objective manner. Recognize that how you define success will be your interpretation of success. But if you take the process seriously and document it, as we demonstrated in the two prior pieces exploring your professional fiduciary standard, you can feel confident that you are satisfying your fiduciary duties of care and loyalty, which is the foundation for success for all the trust’s stakeholders.
In the next piece, we’ll explore investment risk, what it is and what it is not. You may be surprised to learn that risk is almost always something other than financial market volatility.
If you liked this piece and want to continue to receive them, please follow Third Day Capital Management on LinkedIn. And of course, if you have any specific questions, feel free to reach out to us directly. We prefer personal conversations, but email or LinkedIn messages work just fine.

