In July, we looked at the elevated professional fiduciary standard of care and, using a case study, discussed how courts apply it. With this piece, we begin a multi-part exploration of your role as an independent trustee in establishing and overseeing the investment strategy for your trusts. We’ll look at the unique role you play and how it differs from the trust’s investment agents, the factors that must be considered, how conflicts among multiple classes of beneficiaries are managed, whether ESG-oriented strategies are appropriate, and how the investment strategy is documented, periodically reviewed, and when necessary, updated.
To begin, it’s important to understand the unique and non-delegable role you as the trustee play in setting the trust’s overall investment strategy. Unless you have an investment background, all too often you may be tempted to delegate the establishment of the trust’s overall investment strategy to the investment agent(s) responsible for managing the trust’s assets. On the surface, it may seem like the prudent approach to take, especially if the trust is small or only owns publicly traded securities managed by one investment firm. Under the surface, however, it’s a highly risky decision regardless of the simplicity or size of the trust, a clear abdication of what is your sole prerogative and an explicit breach of both your duty of care and duty of loyalty.
While you are allowed, and in some circumstances encouraged, to delegate certain investment-related functions to investment professionals, the obligation to oversee trust assets is an administrative obligation statutorily imposed upon the trustee by the Uniform Prudent Investor Act of 1994 (UPIA) and the Uniform Trust Code (UTC ), among other legal frameworks (some of which we discuss in last month’s pieces). Together, they define the scope with which you must approach the oversight of the trust’s assets and impose upon you different duties (plural) than the duty (singular) imposed upon your investment managers.
Under the UPIA, your investment decisions “must be evaluated, not in isolation but in the context of the trust portfolio as a whole and as part of an overall investment strategy having risk and return objectives reasonably suited to the trust.“[i] The UPIA explicitly requires an overall investment strategy so that your decisions can be evaluated against that strategy. The absence of an overall investment strategy constitutes an explicit breach of the duty of care under the UPIA.
The UTC imposes upon the trustee both a duty of loyalty[ii] and a duty of impartiality[iii], whereas the UTC only imposes upon your investment managers a duty of “reasonable care to comply with the terms of the delegation.”[iv] As such, investment managers have no responsibility to be loyal or impartial to the trust, only to act reasonably within the narrowly defined scope of their agency.
The separation of duties, responsibilities and liability between you as the trustee and your investment manager(s) is also pragmatic. The second section of the UPIA requires you to consider “the purposes, terms, distribution requirements and other circumstances of the trust”[v] when establishing the overall investment strategy and the risk and return objectives of the trust’s assets. Other circumstances of the trust are defined as “other resources of the beneficiaries”[vi], “needs for liquidity, regularity of income, and preservation or appreciation of capital”[vii] and “an asset’s special relationship or special value, if any, to the purposes of the trust or to one or more of the beneficiaries”.[viii]
Although trustees routinely share trust details (such as the legal trust documents) and general, high-level information about the beneficiaries with their investment managers, investment managers are generally not (and should not) be privy to detailed, intimate financial information about the beneficiary. Information about a beneficiary’s other resources and assets, their need or lack thereof for liquidity, and their preference for preservation or appreciation of capital are not details investment managers need to know in order to fulfill their duties. In addition, individual investment managers are generally not aware, nor should they be, of the existence and extent of assets outside of their mandate. They only need to know what their mandate is and how they are expected to fulfill it.
As a result, your legal duties and the fact that you alone possess all of the pertinent information necessary to develop the overall investment strategy set you apart in your obligation to employ a trust-level perspective; you alone have the responsibility and the capability to set the trust’s “North Star”. Involving one of the trust’s investment managers in the development of the overall investment strategy is an intrinsic conflict of interest, a violation of your beneficiaries’ privacy expectations, and likely a breach of your duty of loyalty.
Thankfully, apart doesn’t mean alone. Your non-delegable duty to set the investment strategy doesn’t preclude you from hiring an objective agent to help you. Institutional fiduciaries have employed third-party investment professionals to serve as objective consultants for decades; it used to be a best practice but it’s become so routine that trustees for pension funds, endowments, public and private foundations, and other institutions with investment portfolios are expected to retain professional consultants to help them develop the investment strategy, draft the Investment Policy Statement, and evaluate and oversee their investment managers. Though it may look like delegation, the decisions ultimately remain your prerogative; it’s smart risk-mitigation in the form of objective third-party advice, guidance and support as you fulfil your duties and obligations and exercise your authority for the benefit of the trust and your beneficiaries.
Because drafting the overall investment strategy is not for the faint of heart. You must incorporate the trust’s provisions, limitations, goals and purpose, the grantor’s intentions, and the unique circumstances, needs and rights of the beneficiaries, which often compete or conflict with one another, as would be the case when a trust has both an income beneficiary (who presumably prefers current income at the expense of long-term appreciation) and a remainderman (who presumably prefers the long-term appreciation of the trust assets at the expense of current income).
Moreover, under the UPIA, viewed in the context of the overall trust, any investment / asset could potentially be suitable, and any investment / asset could potentially be unsuitable. As if a virtually unlimited investment universe weren’t daunting enough, you are expected to consider a myriad of economic factors including inflation, the expected tax consequences of investment decisions, the costs associated with potential investments, the expected risk and return of each investment and the correlation of an asset’s risk and return to the risk and return of the other assets in the portfolio and its contribution to the overall risk and return of the entire trust. Oh, and the standard against which your decisions will be judged in a court of law should you ever have to defend yourself? The prudent professional standard, the elevated standard we explored last month.
We plan to unpack a number of these challenges over the coming weeks and months as part of our focus on the investment strategy, so for now, we’ll refrain from diving too deeply into them. We’ll just summarize by noting that setting the investment strategy is a highly complex effort, one that falls squarely on your shoulders as trustee. Nevertheless, you don’t have to set it alone; you just have to be intentional about who you include and exclude and the role they play in the process.
In our next piece, we’ll explore the specific trust circumstances you should incorporate into the trust’s investment strategy; the trust’s purpose, provisions and limitations, the grantor’s goals and intentions, and of course, how various beneficiary characteristics should be accommodated.
If you liked this piece and want to continue to receive them, please follow Third Day Capital Management on LinkedIn. And of course, if you have any specific questions, feel free to reach out to us directly. We prefer personal conversations, but email or LinkedIn messages work just fine.
[i] UPIA §2(b)
[ii] UTC §802
[iii] UTC §803
[iv] UTC §807(b)
[v] UPIA §2(a)
[vi] UPIA §2(c)(6)
[vii] UPIA §2(c)(7)
[viii] UPIA §2(c)(8)

